Inside NOVA: Legislation would bury controversial Haymarket power line

Power lines example provided by Dominion Energy
An example of what a controversial power line through the Gainesville area is expected to look like, according to Dominion Energy.

By Alex Koma  Updated January 23, 2017

Del. Tim Hugo, R-40th District, is now pushing legislation requiring Dominion Energy to bury its controversial western Prince William power line, following through on a campaign pledge he made in the days leading up to the November election.

The utility company is still locked in a battle with state regulators over the 230-kilovolt power line, which is proposed to run through parts of Gainesville to reach a data center in Haymarket. But if Dominion can get permission from the State Corporation Commission to move ahead with the project, Hugo’s bill would ensure that at least part of the power line would be built underground along Interstate 66.

The company is currently hoping to build the power line atop large towers running alongside I-66, but people living nearby have pushed back against that design forcefully over the last few years, over concerns about what it would mean for the environment and local property values.

While a pair of community groups is working to block the project from ever being built,challenging the company’s assertions that the project is necessary to power both the Haymarket data center and stabilize the area’s electrical grid, the power line’s opponents believe constructing it underground would be the most palatable option if it must move forward. That prompted Hugo to promise in late October to introduce such a bill if he were re-elected, and he met that commitment on the first day of the General Assembly’s new session Jan. 10.

“This legislation makes certain that the proposed Haymarket power lines are underground,” Hugo, who doubles as chair of the House Republican caucus, wrote in a statement. “I made a campaign promise to find a solution that protects homeowners’ property values and the historical significance of western Prince William County.”

Dominion has long resisted calls to bury the power line, arguing it would be prohibitively expensive and difficult to do so. State regulators agreed, initially directing the company to route the project through several different Gainesville communities.

Yet, between opposition from Prince William County supervisors and activists, the company has repeatedly had to turn to other plans, settling on the “overhead” option along I-66. Hugo’s bill would force the utility to instead include the project as part of a “pilot program” aimed at studying the feasibility of underground power lines–contingent on the SCC affirming that there is a legitimate need for the project in the first place.

“Directionally, Del. Hugo’s bill seems to lay out a prudent way to expand our experience with underground transmission lines, which is a goal we can support,” Dominion spokesman Chuck Penn wrote in an email. “We look forward to working with him and others as this bill moves through the General Assembly.”

The legislation would also give lawmakers in each locality where the line would be built a say in the process and mandates that the primary purpose of any project included in the program  involve “grid reliability, grid resiliency or to support economic development priorities.” The Haymarket power line opponents have frequently argued that the project is designed solely to benefit the owner of the data center, a subsidiary of online retail giant Amazon, not improve the area’s electrical service.

Hugo’s bill would also allow for any power line included in the program to be built on overhead towers, if the “estimated additional cost of placing the proposed line…underground does not exceed 2.5 times the cost of placing the same line overhead.” Dominion estimates that building the Haymarket project partially underground would cost $167 million in all; the company pegs its overhead option at $51 million, a difference of $116 million, which falls just below the bill’s standard.

Elena Schlossberg — the executive director of the Coalition to Protect Prince William County, one of the groups challenging the project before state regulators — sees the legislation as essentially a “prudent back-up.” She commended Hugo for following through on a campaign promise, when his pledge could have been just “an electioneering gimmick,” though she remains adamant that her group will continue to focus on blocking the entire project.

State regulators have agreed to another consideration of the coalition’s concerns about the need for the project in a February hearing, and they could ultimately decide to cancel the power line construction.

One Reply to “Inside NOVA: Legislation would bury controversial Haymarket power line”

  1. The planned route has had many changes for so long it is difficult to believe what is being said by Dominion today. For years it was only for the data center, now future expansion. If it must be built it should be buried, and along the interstate. The other options proposed are much worse. Buried has been done in, Reston, Arlington and many other places. It would make our county to be like New Jersey along the Jersey Turnpike to be overhead, (any one who has traveled there knows what am saying).

Comments are closed.